For the past three months, fellow ?War Correspondent? Britt Schramm and I have been covering the entire Batman: War Games crossover here at 4 Color Review. At the conclusion of the series, we sat down and discussed what?s good, what?s bad, and possibly what?s next for the Batman Family. A warning for the spoiler sensitive who may not have read all of the War Games books yet, major plot points are discussed below.
Eric: I?m still processing I just don’t know how I feel about it yet. It could be positive, it could be negative. War Games, as a whole, I would give a 2 out of 5 rating, but there were individual issues that were better than that.
Britt: I’m leaning more towards negative in some aspects. The story really did nothing more than make Batman seem more like a head case than ever before. Whatever mythos that was there previously has vanished. I need to start reading the Neal Adams HCs to recover. In total, I’d give it a 1.5 out of 5. I liked the Ten Cent Adventure and a couple of other titles that actually did something while also moving the story along. The others just seemed like filler.
Eric: You?re right. This event was overly long. If it had been done over the course of a month and plotted more tightly, I think I would have enjoyed it more. In the end, yes some big things happened - Orpheus died (although how many times has he appeared since his mini up until they built him up again in the Detective backup prior to War Games) Spoiler died, Black Mask become Boss of Gotham, Batman’s relationship with the cops went south, but did it really require 3 months and 25 comics to accomplish? I’m not so sure.
Britt: Exactly. Sure, stuff happens in this crossover but was it really necessary to drag out the death of Tim’s girlfriend almost four issues? Was the inclusion of Catwoman necessary at all? Her three stories really brought nothing to the table.
Eric: I can understand what they were attempting to do, but some of the books that were included ended up being mere “POV” - story that had already been told in another book being retold from the point of view of a different character. Darla Aquista is one of those characters who was seemingly created for no other purpose than to be cannon fodder. We never really got to know her. And to be honest with you, I’m sort of surprised after using four issues to chronicle her death it didn’t have more immediate impact. I’m sure Tim will reflect on both Darla and Stephanie’s deaths in the future, but it seems like Darla was gone and forgotten in the blink of an eye.
Britt: Darla reminds me of the young unnamed Ensign who would come down with Kirk, Spock and Bones and always seems to get killed at the first instance of a fight. She was doomed to be killed off as soon as she was introduced as a gangster’s daughter.
Eric: And we didn?t even have a red uniform to warn us! I was really hoping for more Catwoman involvement. She definitely got short shrift as far as the crossover goes. Yes, she got to win a decisive victory over Zeiss after being beaten by him so badly last time, but that’s a rivalry tied into the regular continuity of her book that didn’t necessarily have to tie in to War Games.
Britt: Is that previous beating from the current story arc (with Gulacy)? Since I dropped the title, I didn’t know much of the previous history which is a perfect example of why it could’ve been done at another time that had more meaning.
Eric: Yup, Catwoman was nearly killed by Zeiss in her own title a few months ago. Thankfully, she was saved by mysterious Ninjas before he could finish her off. Seriously.
Britt: As far as included books, they could’ve skipped both Catwoman and Legends of the Dark Knight. Catwoman, they could have left out for both my reasons above and because it was never really mixed in tightly with any of Bat titles previously. Legends should have remained what
it was originally intended to be: non-continuity stories.
Eric: I would agree with both of these assessments. I’m not sure that LOTDK has gained much by being pulled into continuity. There are plenty of Bat-titles telling current stories without mixing it in as well.
Let?s Go back to what you were saying about Batman’s continuing “head case” status, I agree. This is disturbing. However, this is something that seems to have been emphasized more and more over the last few years and has been happening for a while prior to War Games.
Britt: Yeah, just not really a good time to be a Batman fan - comics wise, that is.
Eric: Well, I think part of the problem is that after all of the hype around Hush - which I felt was deserved - it’s hard to hit that bar again immediately. Part of the popularity of Hush, in my opinion, can be attributed to the fact that it only ran in one title and didn’t ask readers to pick up a bunch of books to get the whole story. War Games, and I just keep coming back to this, was just too broad. The idea was pretty solid, but the implementation came up somewhat lacking. “Officer Down” was a more satisfying crossover in my opinion.
Britt: “Officer Down” was done better since it was more of a low key, character piece on the inner-working relationships between Gordon and Batman, Gordon and his men/women, the police and Batman. Plus, it set up the very underrated series, Gotham Central. “War Games” is more of a “popcorn” summer movie.
Eric: That?s a pretty good comparison way of looking at the differences between those two crossovers. I don?t think I can come up with anything better than that. So, now, the big question. What are they going to do with things now? Obviously they’ve left a lot of story opportunities available, but it’s where they go from here that will really determine for me whether this is “successful” or not.
Britt: The fractionalization of the Bat-team is somewhat disturbing.
While Batman doing solo stuff might be good, the way his character is being portrayed makes him just this side of the Punisher, which is very bad. The whole thing about Batman is that he’s the only superhero who tries to emulate a family environment in his costumed life. Removing that piece diminishes his character overall.
Eric: He did show some tenderness to Stephanie in the final issue, while she lay dying. A scene that I actually found kind of touching, but you’re right. He was pretty callous to everyone else throughout War Games and has been for quite some time. Batman is a serious character, I wouldn’t want him any other way, but I know that his team are more to him than soldiers and I wish he’d let that show a little more from time to time. He doesn’t have to a touchy-feely new age dad, but he could be a more caring “father.”
Britt: Maybe I went somewhat overboard with the showing of the love between the Bat-family but if you didn’t have any real back story on Batman and his team, most people would wonder if his control over them would borderline on being abusive. And I’m not saying a swing back to the 50’s Batman but still, there are ways to show caring without being touchy-feely.
Eric: Too true. Why bring all of these other heroes into the fold only to keep them at arm’s length? He’s become the uncaring father of a group of especially loving children. You would think he’d recognize this. Of course, he couldn’t even recognize his own plan as the blueprint for what was going on around him, which I also found to be incredibly out of character.
Britt: Right. What type of devotion does he earn from these kids by being an uncaring hard ass? I’m not saying he should be Dr. Phil but he doesn’t have to be the Great Santini all of the time.
Eric: I don’t know, Britt, Dr. Phil can be kind of a hard ass, too!
Britt: But with that southern drawl, Dr. Phil sounds more like Col. Sanders than Col. Nick Fury. He’s so out of character that it’s off putting. Hopefully, Dave Lapham will bring some of the ?Detective? back to the book.
Eric: You know who I feel sorry for? Tim. Robin is just taking a beating lately. He lost two girlfriends in War Games and his dad in Identity Crisis. That isn’t going to be easy to live with, you know?
Britt: Yeah, what are they trying to do - make him Spider-Man? If they were thinking of doing that, they could’ve spaced it out over a couple of years. All at once is a case of too much, too soon.
Eric: It’s certainly got to have some sort of impact for Tim. That is an awful lot of tragedy in a very short period of time. DC solicits seem to indicate that Robin will be moving to Bludhaven in the near future. Fresh start?
Britt: Yeah, I’ve heard. So is Batgirl, I think? What happens to Nightwing? Does he go back to Gotham with his tail between his legs after the whole Blockbuster? Why not move Robin to another place altogether? Right now, some of these moves are rather suspect.
Eric: And I guess we’ve got no choice at this point but to “wait and see!”
Britt: And time to organize FANATIC:
Fans
Against
Nightwing
As
The killer in
Identity
Crisis