With a pretty decent amount of fanfare, DC comics launched their new webcomics initiative yesterday with ZudaComics.com going full-on live. Jeremy Love’s “Bayou” has about a dozen and a half pages already online, and it’s easy to see why it was selected as the first “instant winner” strip, getting a full Zuda contract. But what about the rest of the site?
At the site’s default size, the comics are nearly illegible. The full screen presentation is practically breathtakingly beautiful, but I’d hazard a guess that many, if not most people, aren’t going to use the full screen option. It’s one thing to surf through your daily comics in the morning at work, but it’s another thing entirely to have them take over all of your screen’s real estate. This is actually a pretty significant problem that Zuda’s going to have to figure out soon in order to cement themselves in people’s daily viewing routines, I’d think. Otherwise, I like the the flash interface more than I thought I would have, despite it’s minor Safari issues.
The next issue should be much simpler to solve, but is probably even more important to deal with in the short term. One of the hooks Zuda is using in it’s nascent stage is that new regular strips will be voted on by readers, and those garnering the most vote will receive contracted runs on the site. The problem is, I registered last night, never received my password in email (you aren’t allowed to select your own password for some reason), and despite submitting a request for a lost password twice, I still haven’t seen a single Zuna email.Yes, I’ve checked my junk mail - no sign. I emailed them through their contact form on the site, so well see what happens next. Still, this is a major problem that should have been better dealt with prior to the site launch.
Another site issue that I’ve seen already has user confused is their decision to list comments on the comics and blog postings with the newest at the top rather than the bottom. It’s probably the most minor inconvenience of the three I’ve found, but it’s still counterintuitive and goes against the normal comment flow people have gotten used to on hundreds of thousands of other websites. It’s definitely not going to encourage any sort of meaningful conversation as long as it remains in it’s current configuration, that’s for certain.
As for the comics themselves, there’s good and bad. “Bayou” is definitely worth it’s win, and I’m pretty stoked to see where it goes over the course of it’s run. Of the contest participants, I’d have to say that “High Moon” is my clear favorite, followed by “Battlefield Babysitter,” though the latter has some serious lettering issues. KFR friend Steve Ellis is producing the best art of his career on “High Moon,” and I’d love to place my vote for it i I could just get registered. The rest of the comics range from all right to pretty freaking horrible, but I’m not feeling it’s necessary to hate on them by name since the one thing that’s obvious is that all the creators involved are pouring their best efforts into them.