In the years following John Lennon’s murder, a strange thing happened. It seemed that because he met a tragically violent end, critics hesitated in truly evaluating Lennon’s solo work. In addition, Paul McCartney routinely became the recipient of pot-shots from reviewers, and a generation has been raised thinking that McCartney’s solo output is nothing but mediocre ballads and pop fluff, while Lennon continued breaking ground up until his death. Neither is true, but neither is completely false, either; McCartney has made several masterpieces (McCartney, Ram, Band on the Run, Flaming Pie, Chaos and Creation in the Backyard) and some awful albums (Driving Rain, Off the Ground, Press to Play, Pipes of Peace). Lennon made some horrid records (Sometime in New York City, Mind Games, the unlistenable Two Virgins), some mediocre albums (Walls and Bridges, Double Fantasy), and two all-time greats (Plastic Ono Band, Imagine). Even on their most disappointing albums, however, McCartney and Lennon showed flashes of brilliance. McCartney’s excellent career-overview, Wingspan, evenly divided his work between the “Hits†(Disc 1, which included all his charting singles) and the “History†(Disc 2, which featured all his best lesser-known album tracks). Working Class Hero: The Definitive Lennon, a new 2-disc collection of Lennon’s best solo work, takes a slightly different approach; like Wingspan, it jumbles the chronology of the songs, but this set mixes Lennon’s classics right in with the lost gems. It makes for a fresh listening experience, and an album that contains almost all of what one really needs to hear from Lennon’s sometimes genius, sometimes sophomoric, solo catalog.
The set begins with Lennon’s last truly great song, the joyous “(Just Like) Starting Over,†taken from 1980’s Double Fantasy. The rest of the usual suspects are here as well, including, of course, “Imagine†(a classic, granted, but also hard to swallow, considering Lennon wrote, “Imagine no possessions, I wonder if you can,†while sitting in his mansion), the wonderfully melancholy “Jealous Guy,†and the still-exhilarating “Instant Karma! (We All Shine On).â€
But it’s the inclusion of songs that aren’t well known that make this the best Lennon collection ever released. “Nobody Loves You (When You’re Down And Out)†(from 1974’s Walls and Bridges) may be the best song of Lennon’s entire solo career. Masterfully produced, it contains some of his most honest lyrics, great slide guitar, a soaring middle eight, and would’ve been at home on The Beatles (a.k.a. The White Album). Also present is Mind Games’ beautiful “Out the Blue,†Plastic Ono Band’s relentless “Isolation,†and the excellent, Cheap Trick-backed version of “I’m Losing You,†(from 1998’s Lennon Anthology box set of outtakes).
Like any best-of, there are some head-scratchingly absent tracks. Imagine’s “Crippled Inside,†a raving country send-up, featuring George Harrison on dobro, is essential Lennon, and should be here. Lennon’s jaw-dropping Ronettes cover, “Be My Baby,†the standout track from Lennon Anthology, also deserves to be here. Even more perplexing, due to these absences, is the presence of half-baked songs like “Intuition†and the mind-numbing “Woman is the Nigger of the World.â€
Ultimately, Working Class Hero has all the ups and downs that marked Lennon’s solo output, which makes it a fitting retrospective. The best moments — “Nobody Loves You (When You’re Down And Out),†“Isolation,†“I’m Losing You†– and the worst moments – “Power to the People,†“Woman is the Nigger of the World,†“Intuition†— show that for those who possess it, genius is just a series of moments that sometimes come in spades, or sometimes don’t come at all. It was true for McCartney, and it was true for Lennon.