Superman Hates Cancer Patients, DC Shuts Down Charity Auctions
Author: Stephen Gerding
May 14th, 2008 No Comments »
The other day, ebay was served notice by DC/ WB and in turn passed notice on to a gentleman who was running some Superman related auctions that were set up to benefit the cancer charity, Cadlelighters. Seems that the auction featured original pieces of art featuring the character (some by pretty big name artists, to boot), and someone in the DC/WB hierarchy got their knickers in a twist over it.
I messed up. I just got notice that two of the Superman related auctions have been removed from the site and the rest are probably next. I don’t know what to do now. I have to start canceling auctions and issuing refunds. That means all the fees and such I’m now responsible for which is money i just don’t have, and I have no idea if I’m still obligated to the middleman ebay uses for their charity auctions.
I’ve gone ahead and canceled the auctions still running that featured Warner Bros properties. I’m not sure what to do about the ones (like the ones that were canceled by DC) that are already completed. I’ll be talking to ebay, paypal, missionfish (the people that handle ebay’s charity donations) the artists and auction winners.
Up until this occurrence, DC - and the rest of the comic book publishers out there - have chosen to turn a blind eye to the majority of ebay auctions featuring drawings of their characters. Hell, Tom Derenick, one of DC’s current go-to guys actually got his name and work on the radar by becoming one of ebay’s first celebrity comic book illustrators. The only auctions that get shut down with any true regularity, and even then still manage to get from start to finish with no problems most of the time, are the porno superhero illos.
I’m pretty much expecting this bad publicity to cause DC/WB to either reconsider or throw some of their own money at the charity in order to try to make this bad press go away, but the damage is done. DC/WB have managed to come off as the overbearing, uncaring bullies. I understand completely the concept of protecting your characters, trademarks, etc., but I can’t imagine it would do any damage to your company if you were to provide some sort of out or provision allowing people to create and sell fan art, especially in the case of a charity benefit! Or am I delusional?
I’ve already pulled the auctions from round two of the fund raiser that featured Warner Bros properties. I am going to refund and return the art from the first round that featured DC characters so they cannot point at me and say “Look at the money you’ve made from our properties.”
Should things get straightened out with the WB and I get their permission, I can always relist the items later.
So yeah. Here’s hopin’ I don’t have to swallow the costs of the completed auctions with ebay’s charity middleman.*
*Edit, turns out I do. Yay.












